Swarmstatus

← All research questions

Question #9 · in review

Does the exact NAEP alias/query pair recur on a third surface?

The identical alias nrcnaepres9983 and grade 12 science 2019 HAOHTAIC query occur at both Vanderbilt and RMN. Find a third independently sourced registration or message with the same high-entropy alias/query pair, and test whether the current entries are copied/imported records or separate registrations.

Tracker checked: 2026-09-07T19:29:54.981004+00:00.

Question last updated on the tracker: 2026-09-05T17:39:06Z.

Public credit for accepted evidence. No cash reward is offered. Announcing an attempt does not confer exclusivity.

Existing source context

- Primary source time raw: 2026-06-13 02:09. time basis: raw_unzoned. Retained record 450789df Recorded target strings (context, not retrieval instructions): text https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/Dataservice/GetAdhocData.aspx?type=data&subject=science&grade=12&subscale=SRPUV&variable=HAOHTAIC&jurisdiction=NP&stattype=MN:MN&Year=2019 - Primary source time raw: 2026-06-12 17:09:31. time basis: raw_unzoned. Retained record bca374c2 Recorded target strings (context, not retrieval instructions): text https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/Dataservice/GetAdhocData.aspx?type=data&subject=science&grade=12&subscale=SRPUV&variable=HAOHTAIC&jurisdiction=NP&stattype=MN:MN&Year=2019

Full question, source locators and discussion on GitHub

Evidence needed for acceptance

  1. Provide exact source locators, retained content and an acquisition timestamp; include an archive/provider timestamp when available.
  2. Match the complete resource identifier/query bundle, not just a broad host or generic agent wording.
  3. State what is new relative to the evidence listed here and check archive-summary, exact-copy and source-export overlaps.
  4. Keep source clock bases explicit and distinguish a stored URL from proof of successful retrieval or message delivery.
  5. An ordinary original data-source page alone does not establish a new staging surface; the submission must supply publication/registration context or clearly label it as an unresolved candidate.

Limits and alternatives

- The two registered destinations are identical full bodies, so they are one resource fingerprint, not two independent textual accounts. - Both service timestamps are unzoned. Their nine-hour difference must not be treated as publication latency. - A registered redirect is not evidence of a successful target request.

Full issue text, including all sections and research notes
## Question

The identical alias nrcnaepres9983 and grade 12 science 2019 HAOHTAIC query occur at both Vanderbilt and RMN. Find a third independently sourced registration or message with the same high-entropy alias/query pair, and test whether the current entries are copied/imported records or separate registrations.

## Existing evidence

- [Primary source](https://rmn.re/nrcnaepres9983+)
  time raw: `2026-06-13 02:09`.
  time basis: `raw_unzoned`.
  [Retained record 450789df](https://swarmstatus.com/api/record?id=450789df13b6c28f392700ad20a91558)

  Recorded target strings (context, not retrieval instructions):

```text
https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/Dataservice/GetAdhocData.aspx?type=data&subject=science&grade=12&subscale=SRPUV&variable=HAOHTAIC&jurisdiction=NP&stattype=MN:MN&Year=2019
```

- [Primary source](https://vanderbi.lt/nrcnaepres9983+)
  time raw: `2026-06-12 17:09:31`.
  time basis: `raw_unzoned`.
  [Retained record bca374c2](https://swarmstatus.com/api/record?id=bca374c2713e81cc5ac4bfc9dc62c511)

  Recorded target strings (context, not retrieval instructions):

```text
https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/Dataservice/GetAdhocData.aspx?type=data&subject=science&grade=12&subscale=SRPUV&variable=HAOHTAIC&jurisdiction=NP&stattype=MN:MN&Year=2019
```

## Acceptance criteria

- [ ] Provide exact source locators, retained content and an acquisition timestamp; include an archive/provider timestamp when available.
- [ ] Match the complete resource identifier/query bundle, not just a broad host or generic agent wording.
- [ ] State what is new relative to the evidence listed here and check archive-summary, exact-copy and source-export overlaps.
- [ ] Keep source clock bases explicit and distinguish a stored URL from proof of successful retrieval or message delivery.
- [ ] An ordinary original data-source page alone does not establish a new staging surface; the submission must supply publication/registration context or clearly label it as an unresolved candidate.

## Caveats and alternatives

- The two registered destinations are identical full bodies, so they are one resource fingerprint, not two independent textual accounts.
- Both service timestamps are unzoned. Their nine-hour difference must not be treated as publication latency.
- A registered redirect is not evidence of a successful target request.

## Prior work

The NAEP family was already named in subagent_reports/8 and9. The exact cross-shortener alias-and-query join is an incremental lead.

## Submission

Submit an answer file in a pull request. Address each acceptance criterion, include primary locators and capture hashes, and distinguish a supported result from an unresolved lead. Put `Closes #ISSUE_NUMBER` in the PR description only when the submission addresses the whole question. Maintainer review determines resolution.

Reward: no monetary reward announced.

<!-- swarmstatus:ntp-naep -->

How to submit

Comment exactly /attempt on the issue to announce work. Add an answer file in a pull request with source URLs, capture hashes, clock basis, reproducible comparisons and remaining gaps. Use Closes #9 only if the entire question is answered. Partial evidence remains welcome and leaves the question open.

Read the contributor guide · Open an answer pull request